Take your project career to new heights with AIPM membership. Join now to unlock the benefits of Australia’s leading body for project professionals.
Take the quiz
Join thousands of project professionals across Australia who have powered their career prospects with RegPM™ certification.
The demand for project management skills continues to grow across a range of industries, and professionals are building lucrative and rewarding careers.
For nearly 50 years, the AIPM has been driving project management across Australia.
12th Oct 2021
The important thing to remember about both Agile and Waterfall is neither are technically a project management methodology. Instead, Agile can be defined as a mindset to approaching projects which provides flexibility, while Waterfall offers a pre-defined framework to follow that is sequential in nature.
Agile includes a set of principles and values that came to life in 2001, created by 17 technology leaders. Underneath the umbrella of Agile are a range of frameworks and product delivery methods, such as Scrum, Lean, Six Sigma, and Kanban. Agile frameworks and methods do not generally manage the project lifecycle, rather provide a flexible and iterative solution, which allow you to adapt as the situation demands.
Want to learn more? Check out our guide, Agile: Everything You Need to Know.
Waterfall, on the other hand, is much more linear, focusing on up front planning with requirements fully defined before a project commences. Like its name suggests, work cascades, much like a waterfall, through different project phases. Each phase needs to be completed before the next one can begin.
“In Waterfall, members of a team work on their part of a project sequentially: define, design, build, test, deploy and maintain. Practices used by teams working in a more Agile way lead away from Waterfall in aim of better flow, more teamwork, and a greater focus on business value. Together, Agile team members focus on delivering outcomes rather than individually delivering a single pre-defined component of a project.”
Melinda Harrington, Enterprise Agile Coach at Woolworths Group
As always, choosing which approach (Agile or Waterfall) is right for your project is entirely dependent on the nature of the project you have in mind and the culture and type of organisation you work for. Of course, the reality might be that a hybrid Agile Waterfall approach makes the most sense for your project but there are some general rules of thumb.
Agile makes sense where a project is based on incremental progress, complex deliverables or consists of multiple, not always sequential timelines. Projects that require cohesive and collaborative but cross-functional teams to deliver will need to take an Agile approach. If processes or roles are unclear it makes room for figuring it out as the project goes along. It also allows for involving the project client at any stage along the way. Products that are developed in stages, updates or versions are particularly suited to Agile.
Waterfall is usually more suited to less complex projects or those that have well defined requirements, processes and roles for team members. Single delivery timeframes with lots of detail and an expectation that very little is likely to change along the way are ideal. Waterfall also works well when the client is not required to be heavily involved beyond the initial brief and final delivery. From a management point of view, Waterfall can often make sense for fixed-price or contract dependent projects in order to lessen the risk of budget or delivery over-runs.
So take the time to consider the best way forward before you get underway. Know your project goals and determine the variables, dependencies and activities that are crucial for your project. Identify the metrics and success factors that are most critical and review each approach for the best match. Engage your team in the decision-making process and assess their familiarity and experience with different project management approaches and frameworks. Finally, whatever choice you make, stick to it! Changing horse mid-race rarely ends well.
Did you know here at the Australian Institute of Project Management, you can gain recognition for a completed certification which includes some Agile credentials? Find out how you can be automatically granted the AIPM Certified Practising Project Practitioner (CPPP) level of RegPM.
Take our quick self-evaluation quiz to assess your project experience and help you determine your certification level.
A contract management plan is key to successful contract management. Find out why you need one and how to create one here.
Learn about the contract management process and build your contract management skills with practical tips from a lawyer.
Find out about the range of project delivery methodologies and how you can build robust project delivery skills.